Learn how Maryland DHS uses AI to analyze the case notes their workforce was already writing →

Visibility & Reporting

Families Don't Fit in Boxes

October 13, 2022
•
5 min. Read

We are at the beginning of a significant shift in child welfare information systems, and we are excited about the possibilities. Between us, we have more than 40 years of experience as child welfare professionals. Throughout our careers, we've encountered systems that created more administrative work than practical support for caseworkers. The next generation of Comprehensive Child Welfare Information Systems (CCWIS) has an opportunity to change that.

One of the primary goals of CCWIS is to help agencies become more data-driven. Better access to data can help agencies identify trends, understand which practices are working, and make more informed decisions about services and outcomes. But achieving that goal requires access to all agency data, including both structured information and unstructured data such as case notes and communications.

The Problem With Too Many Checkboxes

We're concerned about a trend toward reducing unstructured data by converting more information into structured fields, such as checkboxes and drop-down menus.

There is certainly value in structuring repetitive information that can be consistently captured. But most case notes should remain free-form text. Families have unique circumstances and needs that cannot always be captured in predefined categories.

Consider a few examples:

  • A child's sleeping arrangements: A checkbox might indicate that a child has their own bed. But it won't explain that the child refuses to sleep in that bed because of trauma-related nightmares. That context matters when understanding the child's needs.
  • Housing insecurity: A checkbox for eviction doesn't tell us whether a family was evicted in the past, is currently facing eviction, or is at risk of losing housing. It also doesn't explain why the family is struggling to pay rent, whether due to unemployment, underemployment, or other circumstances.
  • Safety and risk assessments: Risk is rarely black and white. Checkboxes and numerical scales can oversimplify complex situations, particularly for less experienced workers. A simple data entry error can also have significant consequences. Case notes documenting a worker's observations and interactions provide important context that a single field cannot capture.

These examples illustrate why narrative information is so important. Structured data can tell us what happened, but case notes often help explain why and provide the context needed to understand a family's circumstances.

Using NLP to Make Better Use of Case Notes

The answer isn't to choose between structured and unstructured data. Agencies need both.

Innovations like Natural Language Processing (NLP) make it possible to analyze large volumes of free-form text and turn that information into insights that agencies can use. Rather than asking caseworkers to document everything in checkboxes, agencies can use technology to unlock the value already contained in their case notes.

With federal funding, advances in NLP, and ACF's support for systems that reflect individual state child welfare practices, there is an opportunity to build information systems that genuinely support the workforce.

Building Systems That Support Child Welfare Practice

The next generation of CCWIS should not repeat the mistakes of the past. Modernization should be about more than meeting reporting requirements or collecting additional structured data. It should make information more accessible, improve decision-making, and support the complex work of serving children and families.

Families don't fit into boxes. Our technology shouldn't force their stories into them, either.